Domoticz vs home assistant reddit others Have been toying around a fair bit with automation (mostly scheduling/motion sensors) over the last 9 months or so. And Domoticz has a event log where we can add actions on event . Additionally, both are fairly mature products that have been around for over a decade. I can say both platforms have evolved tremendously over the years. Smartthings was dead simple to use and a lot of integrations with other products. Security management is more hands-on, requiring you to set up and configure security measures such as WAF. I also think while HomeKits automation is nice it isn't as powerful as Home Assistant. On iPhone there are a few Basically a manual install of the HA supervisor. Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. They both integrate with many other ecosystems. I spent a recent weekend trying out HA to see if it would be worth integrating as a front end for my existing Hubitat setup, and some of it might be HAOS instead of home assistant core, but I hated that the constant checkconnect/version check phoning home, the containers, calling home to the partner cloud provider, and when I started digging Hi All, Back in 2016 I started my home automation with Home assistant, but because of the scripting that had to be done back in the days I switched to Domoticz, but I’ve always kept following Home assistant. This Reddit is aimed at the education and support for the community. Reolink Camera turn on Light when motion detected - Home assistant PoE Camera Question I have a series of wired in Sensor lights surrounding the home, the sensors on them are ok but I would like to somehow turn on these lights when the Camera Detects motion (person or Vehicle). It also includes cards for controlling entities (with more to come), separators to divide content into categories, and a footer for opening pop-ups. home assistant has so much support with different devices. Lots of people use the two of those together actually, since Home Assistant gives you a self hosted, open source solution for breaking your smart devices free from cloud services and node-red gives you the ability to do with those devices pretty much everything you could do with IFTTT. I've been happy with ZWaveJS so far. I’ve posted several time on this sub in the past years, and as we have made much progress in the past year, I wanted to get some feedback on our software from the community :) I started with Home Assistant, a z-wave stick and a half dozen dimmer switch about 6 months ago then switched to Hubitat about 2 weeks ago. r/homeassistant A chip A close button. There are some awesome dashboards you can find online that really show off the power I have used HomeBridge in the past, and then moved to Home Assistant and have been using that for the past few years. Hey, as I've said before, I'm new to Home Assistant, and I'm looking forward to use both Domoticz and Home Assistant for some personal things. I'm starting to move all my stuff from Smartthings over to Home assistant. SmartThings vs. Hi ! I’m the core maintainer of Gladys Assistant, an open-source smart home software that runs primarily on the Raspberry Pi. Loads of people are going to recommend Home Assistant (this sub might as well be a HA sub). Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. I usually turn this on and name the flow e. Come and join us today! Members Online. I think openhab is great and so is it’s community, but most of my devices are zigbee (most of them don’t have direct zigbee support on openhab neither in home assistant) and I am using zigbee2mqtt to interact with them, which has great support with home assistant, but not so good with openhab (I know I could add them manually, Domoticz comparisons to Home Assistant Similarities. Think of it as practically identical to the full home assistant operating system image, but instead of using the HA OS, you use your own install of Home Assistant took the top spot with 264 votes (out of a total ~1,900 participants)! Congrats on leaving such a positive impact on the self-hosted community, and thank you to all of the Home Assistant developers who work so hard to deliver new functionality and plugins! This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. The cost of replacing their speaker/mics with home assistant is the main reason. The official Python community for Reddit! Stay up to date with the latest news, packages, and meta information relating to the Python programming language. Luckily, both development and projects communication are done in English while the products itself is multilingual. I want to slowly transition from Domoticz to HA, so I need to leave Domoticz controlling things for the time being and start to get HA to control Domoticz and then once that's working I can then start to migrate over each Yes, using iCloud in Home Assistant generates these. Available for free at home-assistant. You can implement your own WAF solutions or use add-ons for enhanced security. I got latent alerts like that from Apple when I did the exact same thing, and I was able to confirm Home Assistant was signing in at the same time. The roadmap is basically "Throw it against the wall and Im a Domoticz guy and Ive half moved away a few times. Home Assistant, Synology DSM 7. Then, I started using a bit of Zigbee using the ZHA integration. All of my automation logic is in node red. ; Installation Process: Both OpenHAB and Home Assistant offer straightforward installation processes, with options for Raspberry Pi, Docker, or server But let's not count that there aren't a lot of devices that are compatible with HomeKit. Home Assistant has a pre-made image you can flash to an SD card, pop into a Raspberry Pi, and BOOM. Hi I'm just starting on my journey of moving from Domoticz to Hass (technically Home Assistant as I'm running it on an existing Docker setup, so no hass. The home notifies me if the AC is running and any window or door is open. The home basically starts building a routine and you mesh with it. My problem was the slowness and the server randomly going offline. In the past years it evolved to the tool it is now and I think it’s time to switch back to Home Assistant. And about 20% in homekit, but eventually I’ll probably move almost all to home assistant. 'FLOW: Living motion lights'. Background: We have an RPi with Z-Wave (AeonLabs USB) for heating and LightwaveRF (Rfxcom) for lighting serving our 5-person shared-house-cum-hackspace. Have migrated over to the new JS addon and so far seems great. Powered by a worldwide community of tinkerers and DIY enthusiasts. I’m wondering what CasaOS can do that Home Assistant can’t. Differences Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. I ended up trying out OpenHAB and Home Assistant - and ended up with the latter mostly thanks to Xiaomi Air Purifier integration working out of the box. Some of my examples: Frigate NVR: local NVR with object detection. Home Assistant now sees around 500 to 700 different community topics per week, making it a very active and lively open source Ah I see. 0 & Domoticz Drivers Hi All, This is my first post on these forums - as you can see from the subject, I am giving up on HA. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi It seems that most newer devices support either Smartthings or Home Assistant. We've also started a list of things we rely on Google home for, and in the meantime, when I have time, I plan to look to see if I can find a replacement for them using home assistant voice assist Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. That alone for me is huge because there’s a good chance someone has had the same problem. Ultimately I end up back at Domoticz. So which one to choose? Today we are pitching two of the Could be Home Assistant or node-red. Apple calls it a web browser because Home Assistant is pretending to be one, and is clearly not an iPhone, a Mac, an iPad, etc. What made you switch to Home Assistent and what benefits did it bring? I get the most benefit from the integrations. But I’m having some thoughts about how to do this. Z-Wave JS and Wallmote Quad scenes to work with Node-RED . " End goal is the same, using Google Home to interface with Domoticz to control my OP's comment: After my usual research and seeing reddit suggesting for Home Assistant, I'll divert my energy into it. Maybe create a action that send http api into hass? Any1 that has testet this? View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. While Home Assistant OS can manage containers and automate your home, I’m still unsure which option to choose. I wrote a handful of scripts with help from the internet, Python, Lua, etcall provided by Domoticz; my home is a bit mixed up Coincidence or not: Both the founders of Domoticz and Home Assistant are Dutch. The reality is that the amount of flexibility that it affords combine with its pace of development means that there is a very steep initial learning curve, that is more akin to climbing a cliff. So much faster than my Vera. Eventually I installed Home Assistant, but kept my ZWave on Vera. So go with Zigbee if you want to have full control of them. My home is kitted out with multiple Google Homes, Sonos One, Hue lights (+ dimmer switches and motion sensors), Tuya-rebranded WiFi smart plugs, Harmony Hub (for entertainment system control). I am aware theat scene commands are on the TODO list but wa shoping for some pointers to get the scenes working using Node-RED. from home assistant into homekit you’ll need to run the homekit integration there. Home Assistant was the first thing that I stumbled upon, I wasn’t aware of the other options. Available for free at home Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. There is a Home Assistant OS that is not Ubuntu 20 that can be installed on the NUC. Home Assistant. Open comment sort options Their Domoticz app for Android is amazing as well, looks good (Material design), but most importantly; works well. The nice side effect is most home assistant 'nodes' have a little checkbox at the bottom that says 'expose to home assistant' and a name. This community is still alive and well on the forums, as well as on sites like Reddit. Integrating Domoticz with Google Home The IF portion will be Google Assistant (the thing Google Home is leveraging). and complaints on the new Anker/Eufy EufyCam. com with the ZFS community as well. Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Recently, I started using Home Assistant, but I noticed that it has fewer features than Home Assistant OS because it lacks a supervisor and container management. Thank you all for valuable advice. Home Assistant seems to have (maybe I’m biased because I obviously only search for HA stuff) way more support/docs/users than OpenHab. But it’s default UI looks a bit outdated. io). Here a topic here for the Sinope you will find a lot of information : Sinope Line Voltage Thermostats and the Neviweb HACS integration : GitHub - claudegel/sinope-130: Neviweb130 custom component for Home Assistant to manage devices connected via a GT130 and wifi devices from Sinopé Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Can't exactly go out and buy home assistant hardware all at once. Perfect to run on a Raspberry Pi or a local server. This is the most involved way to install Home Assistant. Here you will choose your key phrases like: "Turn on kitchen lights. I think Home Assistant is superior in just about every way except 1, integration with Alexa. So thats what you’ll need to use your conbee II with homekit. For Home Assistant, Alexa integration is $5/mo or a very complex system requiring you own AWS account. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. Both have powerful interfaces and the ability to support complex automations. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. Hmm. Then in Home Assistant (my "main" software), I installed the HomeKit Controller (make sure it's "HomeKit Controller" and not just "HomeKit") integration so I can control all my Homebridge plugins in Home Assistant. io. Available for free at home However, there are a plethora of options out there from Home Assistant, OpenHAB, Domoticz, Hubitat and HomeSeer are just a couple of options available. Neither of which I liked, both have steep learning curves and require extensive twiddling to get working. I use Home Assistant to connect the devices that aren't HomeKit compatible. I know the Google Home Mini and Nest are supported by Home Assistant, but connecting the Google Speakers to Home Assistant will mean I lose the privacy advantage. g. Domoticz has many similarities with Home Assistant (and openHAB). Matter really doesn't matter for these guys because they were designed to work with many types of devices, unlike every other brand out there that tries to trap you in their ecosystem. So, should I be moving away from Domoticz, and if so to what? How customisable is Smartthings - can it do I'm quite happy with Domoticz. If you want to get zigbee/zwave/etc. Home Assistant, being open-source, relies on the community and third-party tools for security enhancements, including WAF-like features. No linking to product sales, affiliate links, self promotional links I’m mainly running homekit as a front end, with about 80% of my automations in home assistant. The good way to go is Home Assistant + devices that have local API option available (so they are not dependent on cloud service - usually manufacturer running his own servers), that way your devices work even when there's no internet connection, they work without any latency (lot of servers are not very quick, so for example pressing a switch to turn on a light would make the This gem is in their glossary: "Home Assistant is a full UI managed home automation ecosystem that runs Home Assistant" Overall, this is a project by tinkers for tinkerers. Some annoyances with my door lock, and It's a new card collection for Home Assistant that allows you to create animated pop-ups. . Then I expose them all back to homekit. Platform Overview: OpenHAB and Home Assistant are both open-source home automation platforms that support Amazon Alexa Echo and devices using Zigbee and Z-Wave protocols. Not to mention HA has an awesome “Add On” store which is basically a library of services to self host. I am a home assistant user. Home assistant just maintains state. I'm looking to set up a home automation system for my new house. I also use home assistant for more complex automations that adds them to HomeKit. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit Home Assistant / Domoticz / Solid State Relays 12V bus . Oh, I see that clearly. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. This is just the beginning. as for now i have about Domoticz versus Home Assistant¶ Domoticz has a very powerful event and scripting engine, an active community and lot’s of plugins. Now I'm expanding into plugs, locks, and all sorts of things, but the blinds are still the core of my home assistant experience. I haven´t really found any significant advantage of Domoticz over Home Assistant or OpenHab. OpenHAB for flexible UI configuration or if you have real end-users. and more are added I am using Domoticz on Raspberry since 5 years. Recently, I migrated my ZWave setup to Home Assistant using ZWaveJS. I started out with ZWave on a Vera hub. I'm interested in voice commands and text to speech features, so I'm considering using Home Assistant or just Google Home. There is alot of question regarding integration between Domoticz and Home Assistant. Home Assistant My base protocol that I’m using is Zwave+ and I’m wondering if there is some way to migrate the zwave settings from Domoticz to Home Assistent, or if there is a way to run both There are two main choices - Home Assistant and OpenHAB. It tries to focus on simplicity (auto discover things when possible and/or feasible), a mobile first responsive and pretty user interface, and everything being modeled on the idea of an event bus. Took about 6 months until I actually got the home assistant instance running, but totally worth it. Join and Discuss evolving technology, new entrants, charging infrastructure, government policy, and the ins and outs of EV Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Got pretty much each sensor working and individual bits of code working to read them but then kinda lost the motivation/end of my ability to tie it all together into one working package. I think it was a great platform at some point, however, the community is not as strong as it used to be. Ive tried it - its excellent but considerably less user friendly than Domoticz. OpenHab vs Home Assistant Vs Domoticz: Conclusions Domoticz. In specific, this document helped inspire u/balloob to write Home Assistant the way he did Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. Home Assistant, Hubitat, Smarthings, Home Seer, Open Hab all are what I call brand agnostic. This is the Reddit community for EV owners and enthusiasts. I will try to explain my reasoning in a non-biased way, I am not trying to annoy anyone, just give a POV. I've taken a plunge into home automation of any kind only recently and I was searching for software to tie it together. Wall switches and wall-mounted remotes can control all lights, and an Echo Plus with emulated Hue gives me local on/off dimming voice control without exposing my Home Assistant to the internet (not using Nabu Casa or similar). The blinds! We just bought a new house last year and I ordered zigbee-enabled motorized blinds. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. practicalzfs. dzVentz, lua, blocky, python. After using Home Assistant and openHAB, I find Home Assistant to provide easier customization options, with cleaner user interfaces. Whilst writing this, I'm read through all the details of the different systems and it's just overwhelming. You are right about setup costs vs control, but I'm not entirely sure if this is a home assistant issue. I'm running Home Assistant as a virtual machine and Homebridge as a background service. Home Assistant is what I am using now and I haven't looked back. Ha, I’ve done almost exactly the same but drifted away from the project and never got it finished. Both founders made the home automation platforms open-source, share it for free and allow the community help to get the p Hi! i have been running Domoticz for about 10 years now, im pretty pleased with it but now im thinking of moving everything to homeassistant instead. I have a Nortek HUSBZB-1 stick, 14 integrations, and 60 devices. Expand user menu Open settings menu. So if I want to run both other Ubuntu 20 software and Home Assistant I have to go to the Docker store, but if I don't care about Ubuntu 20, I can install this Home Assistant OS onto the NUC. I have de MQTT integration enabled and I'm able to switch value for some lights and switches configured inside 'configuration. Domoticz Nymea If anyone has some informations about one of these for me, whether they work well for you or not, why you'd advise for or against one, I'd be very happy to hear from you. In retrospect I'd say learning all the logic of home automation with domoticz is a really good start, mainly the out of the box Blockly system is very nice, especially compared to my tl;wr: Domoticz for fast easy UI and network configuration if you're the only end-user. The is an exodus of users moving to OpenHab or Home Assistant. Key Takeaways. I have been using Domoticz for 3+ years, but started to feel it was getting stale, not much changing, I read lots of good reviews about HA so when the SD card in I'm using an old Mac as a server. It is not nearly as easy to use but it works very well when set up right (tons of youtube videos to help with this). It being open source, devices don't take long near as long to become supported. I have a idea 🙂 In Hass we have a api to receive enitiel updated. It was actually quite disappointing to find this out - I'd expected an Today I want to compare three of the main platforms out there, OpenHab vs Home Assistant vs Domoticz. I’ve put most of my decisions into home assistant including lots of zwave and even native homekit devices. Home Assistant vs. "server","name":"Home I am migrating to home assistant. Share Sort by: Best. yaml', but it always shows 'Unknown' state instead of 'ON/OFF'. Hi Guys, Home Assistant is open source home automation that puts local control and privacy first. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us at https://discourse. I am using a RPi3B+ 32GB SD with supervised Home Assistant. At the end of the post, you will have a clear picture of the best option for your Home Assistant is also great, but has a different focus. I might try HA again. gdj pnnl yewdkln ifrk hdtlm dgp sacn llli mcoew zugov